!serverless
!workflow status

Serverless APIGateway Service Proxy

This Serverless Framework plugin supports the AWS service proxy integration feature of API Gateway. You can directly connect API Gateway to AWS services without Lambda.

TOC

- Install
- Supported AWS services
- How to use
- Kinesis
- SQS
- Customizing request parameters
- Customizing responses
- S3
- Customizing request parameters
- Customizing request templates
- Customize the Path Override in API Gateway
- Can use greedy, for deeper Folders
- Customizing responses
- Allow Bindary Types
- SNS
- Customizing responses
- DynamoDB
- Customizing responses
- EventBridge
- Common API Gateway features
- Enabling CORS
- Adding Authorization
- Enabling API Token Authentication
- Using a Custom IAM Role
- Customizing API Gateway parameters
- Customizing request body mapping templates
- Kinesis
- SQS
- SNS

Install

Run serverless plugin install in your Serverless project.

``bash
serverless plugin install -n serverless-apigateway-service-proxy
`

Supported AWS services

Here is a services list which this plugin supports for now. But will expand to other services in the feature.
Please pull request if you are intersted in it.

- Kinesis Streams
- SQS
- S3
- SNS
- DynamoDB
- EventBridge

How to use

Define settings of the AWS services you want to integrate under custom > apiGatewayServiceProxies and run serverless deploy.

$3

Sample syntax for Kinesis proxy in serverless.yml.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis: # partitionkey is set apigateway requestid by default
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
partitionKey: 'hardcordedkey' # use static partitionkey
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis/{myKey} # use path parameter
method: post
partitionKey:
pathParam: myKey
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
partitionKey:
bodyParam: data.myKey # use body parameter
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
partitionKey:
queryStringParam: myKey # use query string param
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
- kinesis: # PutRecords
path: /kinesis
method: post
action: PutRecords
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
YourStream:
Type: AWS::Kinesis::Stream
Properties:
ShardCount: 1
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl https://xxxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/kinesis -d '{"message": "some data"}' -H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

$3

Sample syntax for SQS proxy in serverless.yml.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /sqs
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SQSQueue', 'QueueName'] }
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
SQSQueue:
Type: 'AWS::SQS::Queue'
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl https://xxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/sqs -d '{"message": "testtest"}' -H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

#### Customizing request parameters

If you'd like to pass additional data to the integration request, you can do so by including your custom API Gateway request parameters in serverless.yml like so:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /queue
method: post
queueName: !GetAtt MyQueue.QueueName
cors: true

requestParameters:
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Name': "'cognitoIdentityId'"
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Value.StringValue': 'context.identity.cognitoIdentityId'
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Value.DataType': "'String'"
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.2.Name': "'cognitoAuthenticationProvider'"
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.2.Value.StringValue': 'context.identity.cognitoAuthenticationProvider'
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.2.Value.DataType': "'String'"
`

The alternative way to pass MessageAttribute parameters is via a request body mapping template.

#### Customizing request body mapping templates

See the SQS section under Customizing request body mapping templates

#### Customizing responses

##### Simplified response template customization

You can get a simple customization of the responses by providing a template for the possible responses. The template is assumed to be application/json.

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /queue
method: post
queueName: !GetAtt MyQueue.QueueName
cors: true
response:
template:
# success is used when the integration response is 200
success: |-
{ "message: "accepted" }
# clientError is used when the integration response is 400
clientError: |-
{ "message": "there is an error in your request" }
# serverError is used when the integration response is 500
serverError: |-
{ "message": "there was an error handling your request" }
`

##### Full response customization

If you want more control over the integration response, you can
provide an array of objects for the response value:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /queue
method: post
queueName: !GetAtt MyQueue.QueueName
cors: true
response:
- statusCode: 200
selectionPattern: '2\d{2}'
responseParameters: {}
responseTemplates:
application/json: |-
{ "message": "accepted" }
`

The object keys correspond to the API Gateway integration response object.

$3

Sample syntax for S3 proxy in serverless.yml.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3
method: post
action: PutObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
key: static-key.json # use static key
cors: true

- s3:
path: /s3/{myKey} # use path param
method: get
action: GetObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
key:
pathParam: myKey
cors: true

- s3:
path: /s3
method: delete
action: DeleteObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
key:
queryStringParam: key # use query string param
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
S3Bucket:
Type: 'AWS::S3::Bucket'
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl https://xxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/s3 -d '{"message": "testtest"}' -H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

#### Customizing request parameters

Similar to the SQS support, you can customize the default request parameters serverless.yml like so:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3
method: post
action: PutObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
cors: true

requestParameters:
# if requestParameters has a 'integration.request.path.object' property you should remove the key setting
'integration.request.path.object': 'context.requestId'
'integration.request.header.cache-control': "'public, max-age=31536000, immutable'"
`

#### Customizing request templates

If you'd like use custom API Gateway request templates, you can do so like so:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3
method: get
action: GetObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
request:
template:
application/json: |
#set ($specialStuff = $context.request.header.x-special)
#set ($context.requestOverride.path.object = $specialStuff.replaceAll('_', '-'))
{}
`

Note that if the client does not provide a Content-Type header in the request, ApiGateway defaults to application/json.

#### Customize the Path Override in API Gateway

Added the new customization parameter that lets the user set a custom Path Override in API Gateway other than the {bucket}/{object}
This parameter is optional and if not set, will fall back to {bucket}/{object}
The Path Override will add {bucket}/ automatically in front

Please keep in mind, that key or path.object still needs to be set at the moment (maybe this will be made optional later on with this)

Usage (With 2 Path Parameters (folder and file and a fixed file extension)):

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3/{folder}/{file}
method: get
action: GetObject
pathOverride: '{folder}/{file}.xml'
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
cors: true

requestParameters:
# if requestParameters has a 'integration.request.path.object' property you should remove the key setting
'integration.request.path.folder': 'method.request.path.folder'
'integration.request.path.file': 'method.request.path.file'
'integration.request.path.object': 'context.requestId'
'integration.request.header.cache-control': "'public, max-age=31536000, immutable'"
`

This will result in API Gateway setting the Path Override attribute to {bucket}/{folder}/{file}.xml
So for example if you navigate to the API Gatway endpoint /language/en it will fetch the file in S3 from {bucket}/language/en.xml

##### Can use greedy, for deeper Folders

The forementioned example can also be shortened by a greedy approach. Thanks to @taylorreece for mentioning this.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3/{myPath+}
method: get
action: GetObject
pathOverride: '{myPath}.xml'
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
cors: true

requestParameters:
# if requestParameters has a 'integration.request.path.object' property you should remove the key setting
'integration.request.path.myPath': 'method.request.path.myPath'
'integration.request.path.object': 'context.requestId'
'integration.request.header.cache-control': "'public, max-age=31536000, immutable'"
`

This will translate for example /s3/a/b/c to a/b/c.xml

#### Customizing responses

You can get a simple customization of the responses by providing a template for the possible responses. The template is assumed to be application/json.

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- s3:
path: /s3
method: post
action: PutObject
bucket:
Ref: S3Bucket
key: static-key.json
response:
template:
# success is used when the integration response is 200
success: |-
{ "message: "accepted" }
# clientError is used when the integration response is 400
clientError: |-
{ "message": "there is an error in your request" }
# serverError is used when the integration response is 500
serverError: |-
{ "message": "there was an error handling your request" }
`
#### Allow Binary Type

In order to allow the browser to recognize binary type (e.g. images), add the following.

This would impact Rest API settings which is called by our plugin

`yml
#provider.apiGateway.binaryMediaTypes
provider:
apiGateway:
binaryMediaTypes: "/"
`


$3

Sample syntax for SNS proxy in serverless.yml.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sns:
path: /sns
method: post
topicName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SNSTopic', 'TopicName'] }
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
SNSTopic:
Type: AWS::SNS::Topic
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl https://xxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/sns -d '{"message": "testtest"}' -H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

#### Customizing responses

##### Simplified response template customization

You can get a simple customization of the responses by providing a template for the possible responses. The template is assumed to be application/json.

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sns:
path: /sns
method: post
topicName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SNSTopic', 'TopicName'] }
cors: true
response:
template:
# success is used when the integration response is 200
success: |-
{ "message": "accepted" }
# clientError is used when the integration response is 400
clientError: |-
{ "message": "there is an error in your request" }
# serverError is used when the integration response is 500
serverError: |-
{ "message": "there was an error handling your request" }
`

##### Full response customization

If you want more control over the integration response, you can
provide an array of objects for the response value:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sns:
path: /sns
method: post
topicName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SNSTopic', 'TopicName'] }
cors: true
response:
- statusCode: 200
selectionPattern: '2\d{2}'
responseParameters: {}
responseTemplates:
application/json: |-
{ "message": "accepted" }
`

The object keys correspond to the API Gateway integration response object.

##### Content Handling and Pass Through Behaviour customization

If you want to work with binary fata, you can not specify contentHandling and PassThrough inside the request object.

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sns:
path: /sns
method: post
topicName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SNSTopic', 'TopicName'] }
request:
contentHandling: CONVERT_TO_TEXT
passThrough: WHEN_NO_TEMPLATES
`

The allowed values correspond with the API Gateway Method integration for ContentHandling and PassthroughBehavior

$3

Sample syntax for DynamoDB proxy in serverless.yml. Currently, the supported DynamoDB Operations are PutItem, GetItem and DeleteItem.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- dynamodb:
path: /dynamodb/{id}/{sort}
method: put
tableName: { Ref: 'YourTable' }
hashKey: # set pathParam or queryStringParam as a partitionkey.
pathParam: id
attributeType: S
rangeKey: # required if also using sort key. set pathParam or queryStringParam.
pathParam: sort
attributeType: S
action: PutItem # specify action to the table what you want
condition: attribute_not_exists(Id) # optional Condition Expressions parameter for the table
cors: true
- dynamodb:
path: /dynamodb
method: get
tableName: { Ref: 'YourTable' }
hashKey:
queryStringParam: id # use query string parameter
attributeType: S
rangeKey:
queryStringParam: sort
attributeType: S
action: GetItem
cors: true
- dynamodb:
path: /dynamodb/{id}
method: delete
tableName: { Ref: 'YourTable' }
hashKey:
pathParam: id
attributeType: S
action: DeleteItem
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
YourTable:
Type: AWS::DynamoDB::Table
Properties:
TableName: YourTable
AttributeDefinitions:
- AttributeName: id
AttributeType: S
- AttributeName: sort
AttributeType: S
KeySchema:
- AttributeName: id
KeyType: HASH
- AttributeName: sort
KeyType: RANGE
ProvisionedThroughput:
ReadCapacityUnits: 1
WriteCapacityUnits: 1
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl -XPUT https://xxxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/dynamodb// \
-d '{"name":{"S":"john"},"address":{"S":"xxxxx"}}' \
-H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

#### Customizing responses

##### Simplified response template customization

You can get a simple customization of the responses by providing a template for the possible responses. The template returns the same kind of response for both application/json and application/x-www-form-urlendcoded.

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- dynamodb:
path: /dynamodb
method: get
tableName: { Ref: 'YourTable' }
hashKey:
queryStringParam: id # use query string parameter
attributeType: S
rangeKey:
queryStringParam: sort
attributeType: S
action: GetItem
cors: true
response:
template:
# success is used when the integration response is 200
success: |-
#set($item = $input.path('$.Item')){ "Item": $item }
# clientError is used when the integration response is 400
clientError: |-
{ "message": "there is an error in your request" }
# serverError is used when the integration response is 500
serverError: |-
{ "message": "there was an error handling your request" }
`

##### Full response customization

If you want more control over the integration response, you can
provide an array of objects for the response value:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- dynamodb:
path: /dynamodb
method: get
tableName: { Ref: 'YourTable' }
hashKey:
queryStringParam: id # use query string parameter
attributeType: S
rangeKey:
queryStringParam: sort
attributeType: S
action: GetItem
cors: true
response:
- statusCode: 200
selectionPattern: '2\d{2}'
responseParameters: {}
responseTemplates:
application/json: |-
#set($item = $input.path('$.Item')){ "Item": $item }

`

$3

Sample syntax for EventBridge proxy in serverless.yml.

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- eventbridge: # source and detailType are hardcoded; detail defaults to POST body
path: /eventbridge
method: post
source: 'hardcoded_source'
detailType: 'hardcoded_detailType'
eventBusName: { Ref: 'YourBusName' }
cors: true
- eventbridge: # source and detailType as path parameters
path: /eventbridge/{detailTypeKey}/{sourceKey}
method: post
detailType:
pathParam: detailTypeKey
source:
pathParam: sourceKey
eventBusName: { Ref: 'YourBusName' }
cors: true
- eventbridge: # source, detail, and detailType as body parameters
path: /eventbridge/{detailTypeKey}/{sourceKey}
method: post
detailType:
bodyParam: data.detailType
source:
bodyParam: data.source
detail:
bodyParam: data.detail
eventBusName: { Ref: 'YourBusName' }
cors: true

resources:
Resources:
YourBus:
Type: AWS::Events::EventBus
Properties:
Name: YourEventBus
`

Sample request after deploying.

`bash
curl https://xxxxxxx.execute-api.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/dev/eventbridge -d '{"message": "some data"}' -H 'Content-Type:application/json'
`

Common API Gateway features

$3

To set CORS configurations for your HTTP endpoints, simply modify your event configurations as follows:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors: true
`

Setting cors to true assumes a default configuration which is equivalent to:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors:
origin: '*'
headers:
- Content-Type
- X-Amz-Date
- Authorization
- X-Api-Key
- X-Amz-Security-Token
- X-Amz-User-Agent
allowCredentials: false
`

Configuring the cors property sets Access-Control-Allow-Origin, Access-Control-Allow-Headers, Access-Control-Allow-Methods,Access-Control-Allow-Credentials headers in the CORS preflight response.
To enable the Access-Control-Max-Age preflight response header, set the maxAge property in the cors object:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors:
origin: '*'
maxAge: 86400
`

If you are using CloudFront or another CDN for your API Gateway, you may want to setup a Cache-Control header to allow for OPTIONS request to be cached to avoid the additional hop.

To enable the Cache-Control header on preflight response, set the cacheControl property in the cors object:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'YourStream' }
cors:
origin: '*'
headers:
- Content-Type
- X-Amz-Date
- Authorization
- X-Api-Key
- X-Amz-Security-Token
- X-Amz-User-Agent
allowCredentials: false
cacheControl: 'max-age=600, s-maxage=600, proxy-revalidate' # Caches on browser and proxy for 10 minutes and doesnt allow proxy to serve out of date content
`

$3

You can pass in any supported authorization type:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /sqs
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SQSQueue', 'QueueName'] }
cors: true

# optional - defaults to 'NONE'
authorizationType: 'AWS_IAM' # can be one of ['NONE', 'AWS_IAM', 'CUSTOM', 'COGNITO_USER_POOLS']

# when using 'CUSTOM' authorization type, one should specify authorizerId
# authorizerId: { Ref: 'AuthorizerLogicalId' }
# when using 'COGNITO_USER_POOLS' authorization type, one can specify a list of authorization scopes
# authorizationScopes: ['scope1','scope2']

resources:
Resources:
SQSQueue:
Type: 'AWS::SQS::Queue'
`

Source: AWS::ApiGateway::Method docs

$3

You can indicate whether the method requires clients to submit a valid API key using private flag:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /sqs
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SQSQueue', 'QueueName'] }
cors: true
private: true

resources:
Resources:
SQSQueue:
Type: 'AWS::SQS::Queue'
`

which is the same syntax used in Serverless framework.

Source: Serverless: Setting API keys for your Rest API

Source: AWS::ApiGateway::Method docs

$3

By default, the plugin will generate a role with the required permissions for each service type that is configured.

You can configure your own role by setting the roleArn attribute:

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /sqs
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SQSQueue', 'QueueName'] }
cors: true
roleArn: # Optional. A default role is created when not configured
Fn::GetAtt: [CustomS3Role, Arn]

resources:
Resources:
SQSQueue:
Type: 'AWS::SQS::Queue'
CustomS3Role:
# Custom Role definition
Type: 'AWS::IAM::Role'
`

$3

The plugin allows one to specify which parameters the API Gateway method accepts.

A common use case is to pass custom data to the integration request:

`yaml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /sqs
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SqsQueue', 'QueueName'] }
cors: true
acceptParameters:
'method.request.header.Custom-Header': true
requestParameters:
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Name': "'custom-Header'"
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Value.StringValue': 'method.request.header.Custom-Header'
'integration.request.querystring.MessageAttribute.1.Value.DataType': "'String'"
resources:
Resources:
SqsQueue:
Type: 'AWS::SQS::Queue'
`

Any published SQS message will have the Custom-Header value added as a message attribute.

$3

#### Kinesis

If you'd like to add content types or customize the default templates, you can do so by including your custom API Gateway request mapping template in serverless.yml like so:

`yml


Required for using Fn::Sub

custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'MyStream' }
request:
template:
text/plain:
Fn::Sub:
- |
#set($msgBody = $util.parseJson($input.body))
#set($msgId = $msgBody.MessageId)
{
"Data": "$util.base64Encode($input.body)",
"PartitionKey": "$msgId",
"StreamName": "#{MyStreamArn}"
}
- MyStreamArn:
Fn::GetAtt: [MyStream, Arn]
`

> It is important that the mapping template will return a valid application/json string

Source: How to connect SNS to Kinesis for cross-account delivery via API Gateway

#### SQS

Customizing SQS request templates requires us to force all requests to use an application/x-www-form-urlencoded style body. The plugin sets the Content-Type header to application/x-www-form-urlencoded for you, but API Gateway will still look for the template under the application/json request template type, so that is where you need to configure you request body in serverless.yml:

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- sqs:
path: /{version}/event/receiver
method: post
queueName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SqsQueue', 'QueueName'] }
request:
template:
application/json: |-
#set ($body = $util.parseJson($input.body))
Action=SendMessage##
&MessageGroupId=$util.urlEncode($body.event_type)##
&MessageDeduplicationId=$util.urlEncode($body.event_id)##
&MessageAttribute.1.Name=$util.urlEncode("X-Custom-Signature")##
&MessageAttribute.1.Value.DataType=String##
&MessageAttribute.1.Value.StringValue=$util.urlEncode($input.params("X-Custom-Signature"))##
&MessageBody=$util.urlEncode($input.body)
`

Note that the ## at the end of each line is an empty comment. In VTL this has the effect of stripping the newline from the end of the line (as it is commented out), which makes API Gateway read all the lines in the template as one line.

Be careful when mixing additional requestParameters into your SQS endpoint as you may overwrite the integration.request.header.Content-Type and stop the request template from being parsed correctly. You may also unintentionally create conflicts between parameters passed using requestParameters and those in your request template. Typically you should only use the request template if you need to manipulate the incoming request body in some way.

Your custom template must also set the Action and MessageBody parameters, as these will not be added for you by the plugin.

When using a custom request body, headers sent by a client will no longer be passed through to the SQS queue (PassthroughBehavior is automatically set to NEVER). You will need to pass through headers sent by the client explicitly in the request body. Also, any custom querystring parameters in the requestParameters array will be ignored. These also need to be added via the custom request body.

#### SNS

Similar to the Kinesis support, you can customize the default request mapping templates in serverless.yml like so:

`yml


Required for using Fn::Sub

custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /sns
method: post
topicName: { 'Fn::GetAtt': ['SNSTopic', 'TopicName'] }
request:
template:
application/json:
Fn::Sub:
- "Action=Publish&Message=$util.urlEncode('This is a fixed message')&TopicArn=$util.urlEncode('#{MyTopicArn}')"
- MyTopicArn: { Ref: MyTopic }
`

> It is important that the mapping template will return a valid application/x-www-form-urlencoded string

Source: Connect AWS API Gateway directly to SNS using a service integration

$3

You can customize the response body by providing mapping templates for success, server errors (5xx) and client errors (4xx).

> Templates must be in JSON format. If a template isn't provided, the integration response will be returned as-is to the client.

#### Kinesis Example

`yml
custom:
apiGatewayServiceProxies:
- kinesis:
path: /kinesis
method: post
streamName: { Ref: 'MyStream' }
response:
template:
success: |
{
"success": true
}
serverError: |
{
"success": false,
"errorMessage": "Server Error"
}
clientError: |
{
"success": false,
"errorMessage": "Client Error"
}
``